Virginia Tech • Status: Settled
Blacksburg, Virginia
Speech First v. Sands, et al
April 8, 2021
Recent Activity: April 6, 2024: Speech First secures favorable settlement with VA Tech.
Case launch: April 8th, 2021 (United States District Court for the Western District of Virginia)
Issues being challenged:
- Discriminatory-harassment policy
- Bias-related incidents policy
- Computer policy
- Flyering policy
“Virginia Tech and its administrators have silenced, intimidated, and suppressed students’ speech for years with these policies. Our student members actively censor what they say, hide their views on social or political issues, and avoid speaking up in the classroom because they know they can be reported by their peers to the University’s Bias Incident Response Team. Open discourse and inquiry should be a staple at universities; it shouldn’t be monitored for bias and ‘intervened’ against by university administrators. Virginia Tech’s goal of ‘eliminating’ speech it disagrees with does not supersede the First Amendment.”
-Cherise Trump, Executive Director, Speech First
Featured
- Settlement Agreement April 9, 2024
- Justice Thomas's Dissenting Opinion March 4, 2024
- Speech First Statement on SCOTUS Decision March 4, 2024
- Speech First Reply Brief on Petition for Cert. October 26, 2023
- Press Release for Filing of Petition for Cert August 14, 2023
- Petition for Certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court August 14, 2023
- Press Release on Fourth Circuit Decision May 31, 2023
- Fourth Circuit Decision May 31, 2023
- Speech First Complaint against VA Tech April 8, 2021
- Press Press Release for Speech First Complaint against VA Tech April 8, 2021
Case Documents
- Justice Thomas's Dissenting Opinion March 4, 2024
- Settlement Agreement April 9, 2024
- Speech First Statement on SCOTUS Decision March 4, 2024
- Speech First Reply Brief on Petition for Cert. October 26, 2023
- Alliance Defending Freedom & Manhattan Institute Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Americans for Prosperity Foundation Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Buckeye Institute Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Foundation for Moral Law Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Liberty Justice Center & Cato Institute Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Parents Defending Education Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Southeastern Legal Foundation Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Alumni Free Speech Alliance Amicus Brief September 18, 2023
- Press Release for Filing of Petition for Cert August 14, 2023
- Press Release on Fourth Circuit Decision May 31, 2023
- REPLY BRIEF OF APPELLANT SPEECH FIRST April 1, 2022
- Speech First, Inc v. Sands et al; Amicus Brief by the Southeastern Legal Foundation January 18, 2022
- Speech First, Inc v. Sands et al; Amicus Brief by the Liberty Justice Center, Cato Institute, and American Council of Trustees and Alumni January 18, 2022
- Speech First, Inc v. Sands et al; Amicus Brief by the Alliance Defending Freedom January 18, 2022
- Speech First, Inc v. Sands et al; Amicus Brief by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education January 18, 2022
- SPEECH FIRST V. SANDS ET. AL BRIEF OF APPELLANT SPEECH FIRST January 10, 2022
- SPEECH FIRST V. SANDS ET. AL; PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION GRANTED September 22, 2021
- Motion for Leave to File Notice of Supplemental Authority in Virginia Tech Lawsuit July 5, 2021
- PLAINTIFF’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION June 11, 2021
- Virginia Tech Preliminary Injunction Filing April 12, 2021
- SPEECH FIRST V. SANDS ET. AL; COMPLAINT April 8, 2021
Media Coverage
March 14, 2024
Experts raise concerns about SCOTUS silence on college free speech case
The Center Square
March 11, 2024
Supreme Court Shrugs At Extreme Campus Speech Rules
Daily News Record
March 11, 2024
Supreme Court unwisely ducks campus speech issue
Washington Examiner
March 8, 2024
A so-called activist Supreme Court shrugs at extreme campus speech rules
The Washington Post
March 5, 2024
A Bias Response Team Evades Justice at the Supreme Court
The Wall Street Journal
March 4, 2024
Supreme Court declines to rule on bias reporting programs at Va. Tech
The Washington Post
August 22, 2023
Supreme Court asked to intervene in Fairfax and Virginia Tech education lawsuits
Washington Examiner
June 11, 2023
Virginia Tech’s Bias Response Team and the First Amendment
Wall Street Journal
June 11, 2023
Virginia Tech defeats attempt to enjoin university’s policies
VA Lawyers Weekly
June 3, 2023
Virginia Tech bias response team receives favorable ruling from Fourth Circuit majority
Bolly Inside
June 2, 2023
Court Rules Against Free Speech Group, Upholds Virginia Tech Bias Policy
Daily Wire
June 2, 2023
Fourth Circuit majority rules in favor of Virginia Tech Bias Response Team
WFXR
June 2, 2023
Virginia Tech bias policy upheld by appeals court
The Roanoke TImes
May 31, 2023
‘Surveillance State’: Federal Judge Slams Decision To Uphold University’s Bias Reporting Policy In Dissent
Daily Caller
November 11, 2022
Amid lawsuit, judge voices criticism of Virginia Tech policies that limit student speech
The College Fix
May 6, 2022
Federal free speech lawsuit against Virginia Tech continues
The College Fix